wechat_bg

2021-07-12 11:14:11

When the bell rings, hundreds of students flood into the canteen in the Longfu Primary School in Du’an county, where they will enjoy a free meal with hot rice, meat stew, and vegetable stir fry.

Hidden deep in the mountains of southern China’s Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region, the outlying Du’an county has been plagued with poverty for decades and was known as one of the poorest places in China.

A decade ago, steamed soybean with rice was the most common meal for school children at the Longfu school. Without enough nutrition, children in Du’an were generally shorter and thinner than their peers in the rest of the country.

Things have changed since 2011, when the central government initiated an unprecedented program designed to boost nutrition for children in the vast rural regions. Under the program, more than 600 kids at the Longfu school can enjoy a free school lunch daily.

Over the past 10 years, the central government has spent 147.2 billion yuan ($22 billion) on the school meal program, covering 1,762 counties in 29 provinces and 40 million rural students as of May 2020.

“The program has significantly improved the physical condition of rural children,” said Lu Mai, vice chairman of the China Development Research Foundation (CDRF). The foundation launched a program in 2007 to help rural schools improve students’ nutrition, which won the central government’s support and evolved into the 2011 school meal pilot program.

A boy waits to be served at a rural primary school in Wangxia Township, Hainan province, Dec. 9, 2020. Yuan Chen/People Visual

A boy waits to be served at a rural primary school in Wangxia Township, Hainan province, Dec. 9, 2020. Yuan Chen/People Visual

Globally, governments have widely adopted school meal programs as a way to improve child health and encourage school attendance. According to studies by the United Nations’ World Food Program (WFP), as of 2020, more than 150 countries offered various kinds of school meal programs, costing $41 billion to $43 billion annually. More than 90% of the funding came from governments.

“School feeding is a game-changer — for children, for communities, and for countries,” WFP Executive Director David Beasley said in February. “That one meal a day is often the reason hungry children go to school in the first place.”

China’s 10-year effort to expand the school meal program has shown positive results. According to data from the Chinese Center for Disease Control and Prevention, the average height of schoolgirls increased by 1.69 centimeters between 2012 and 2019 in regions covered by the state-backed school meal program. The average height of boys grew by 1.54 centimeters.

But the program faces challenges from the country’s changing economic conditions and people’s evolving appetites. In a decade, the central government’s average subsidy to support the program increased from three yuan per child each meal to four yuan. But during that period, prices for staple foods rose several-fold, adding financial pressure on local authorities and schools. Meanwhile, the program's quality varies among regions depending on local implementation, and the challenge of making the program more sustainable is testing officials’ ingenuity.

In March, the Ministry of Education partnered with the CDRF to launch a review of the school meal program’s operations over the past 10 years. The two institutions will carry out massive assessments involving inspections and interviews across the country to study the achievements and failures of the program.

A cook fries vegetables for students at a primary school in Hefeng County, Hubei province, March 16, 2021. Yang Shunpi/People Visual

A cook fries vegetables for students at a primary school in Hefeng County, Hubei province, March 16, 2021. Yang Shunpi/People Visual

Decade-long effort

Every Monday morning, 20 refrigerated trucks carrying four tons of pork, eight tons of vegetables and fruit, and 10.8 tons of rice visit 300 rural schools in Du’an county. The supplies are enough to feed 80,000 students over the week.

“I like to eat at school more than at home,” Ajian, a fifth-grade student at Longfu school, told Caixin. With meat, vegetables, and unlimited rice, lunch at school has become an essential part of Ajian’s daily life.

Ten years ago, many children like Ajian in Du’an suffered from malnutrition. A survey by the CDRF found that 12 of every 100 rural students in the county showed stunted growth, defined by their height being more than 6 centimeters shorter than that of the average height of their peers in urban areas. Many boarding school students consumed no vitamin C in daily meals.

“Many students ate no fat throughout the week, and there were always students who fainted due to hypoglycemia,” said Wei Jun, a school principal in Du’an.

Although the government has handed out billions of yuan in subsidies to rural families for childhood nutrition since 2008, little of the money was spent on improving children’s meals, the CDRF survey found.

That prompted the central government to revamp the subsidy program and launch the school meal project as part of their poverty relief efforts. A series of policies and investments followed. Between 2012 and 2021, Du’an alone received about 500 million yuan of central government funding for the school meal program, in addition to 96 million yuan for the construction of school cafeterias. The county government also provided 70 million yuan for schools to hire canteen staff.

In November, Du’an was no longer listed as a “deeply poor” county as the local economy expanded. But for many rural families, meals provided by schools remain the main source of nutrition for their kids.

A girl walks carefully with her meal in Jingdezhen, Jiangxi province, Oct. 24, 2016. Xu Zheng/People Visual

A girl walks carefully with her meal in Jingdezhen, Jiangxi province, Oct. 24, 2016. Xu Zheng/People Visual

A challenging task

When Tang Yi took the helm of overseeing the student nutrition program at Du’an county’s education bureau in 2017, he faced mounting challenges to manage food supplies for hundreds of schools in the county. Many schools had fewer than 50 students and were located in isolated mountain areas that were difficult to reach.

Poor management and lax oversight left the county’s school meal project in shambles. The quality of school meals varied widely. In some small schools, the so-called school meal notoriously contained only a packet of cookies or a carton of milk. An audit of the project’s operations between 2011 and 2017 found massive financial fraud and embezzlement, according to Tang.

Du’an was not unique. A 2016 report by China Education Daily newspaper disclosed that some school canteens in northeast China’s Heilongjiang province were subleased to private operators and provided substandard food to students.

“In the past, schools found their own suppliers, and the county provided insufficient supervision,” Tang said.

Since 2019, the Du’an county government consolidated local school food procurement under unified management. All purchases are conducted through public bidding, while spending and product quality fall under the government’s supervision, Tang said. Many other localities have likewise tightened their oversight in recent years, introducing public bidding, unified procurement, and distribution.

While years of effort have improved the school meal program’s ability to provide safe and nutritious meals to many rural students, the project still faces mounting challenges to keep going.

Rising food costs are adding pressure. From 2011 to 2021, the average price of eggs increased more than threefold, from 1.8 yuan per kilo to 6 yuan. The price of pork rose from 4 yuan per kilo to nearly 14 yuan, and rice from 1.2 yuan per kilo to 3.5 yuan, according to Du’an government data. However, since 2014, central government funding for the school meal program has remained unchanged at 4 yuan per person per meal.

The African swine fever that slashed China’s pork production in 2019 and 2020 further rattled the school meal program. “As the pork price surged to 30 yuan per kilo in May 2020, many schools could only afford a little meat in the meals,” Tang said. Pork prices have since eased somewhat.

While the central government subsidy covers most food spending, schools still need to shoulder most of the costs to run the canteens. A study by Shao Zhongxiang, a Ph.D. candidate at Southwest University in Chongqing, found that one school faced additional electricity costs of 40,000 yuan to 50,000 yuan a year to power the cafeterias.

Expenditure on electricity and water to run a canteen can account for 12% to 28% of a school’s total annual spending, according to Zhao Yanyan, an education official in the southern Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region.

Rising labor costs have made it increasingly difficult for school cafeterias to hire enough staff with limited budgets. Caixin learned that 79 out of Du’an’s more than 300 schools now struggle to hire food service workers as the wages they can offer are too low.

In 2020, the Du’an county government spent 7.3 million yuan to help schools hire canteen workers. The county’s total fiscal revenue was 652 million yuan, mainly from agriculture and animal husbandry. The county government-funded local schools’ cafeteria spending on water and power for several years starting in 2012 but stopped after 2016 as it could no longer afford to do so, Tang said.

Some experts said it is time for the central government to increase subsidies for the school meal program. The CDRF suggested that the per capita subsidy should be raised from 4 yuan to 5 yuan per meal. Others said more diverse funding channels should be introduced to expand the program’s financing, including partial payments by students’ families.

Students enjoy a free lunch at a primary school in Rong’an County, Hubei province, 2019. Tan Kaixing/People Visual

Students enjoy a free lunch at a primary school in Rong’an County, Hubei province, 2019. Tan Kaixing/People Visual

Long-term commitment

Now that China’s school meal program has achieved its primary goal of feeding rural kids, it is moving toward improving food quality, several health experts said.

“The new problem is that malnutrition and over-nutrition co-exist among rural students,” said Zhang Fan, a public health expert at Hainan Medical University.

Studies tracking the rural school meal program over the past five years found that although the program has greatly reduced malnutrition, the average nutritional status of rural children remains lower than that of urban kids, and vitamin deficiencies are more common. At the same time, obesity is also increasing.

Caixin found that meals provided in most rural schools in several provinces lack diversity. Only a few schools have nutrition professionals involved in meal arrangements.

Many rural parents tend to give their kids cheap snacks with high sugar and fat, Zhang said, advocating for more public education on nutrition.

In the long run, the school meal program should be supported by legislation and regulations to ensure sustainable operation, added Zhang.

In 2015, then-Vice Minister of Education Lu Xin proposed legislation to support the school meal project. However, related lawmaking has yet to start. Written regulations to assist the program with finance and taxation are also lacking.

Current implementation of the school meal program mainly depends on local authorities’ attitude, Zhang said, adding, “Only when leaders realize the importance of improving nutrition and understand how the program should be carried out can the project achieve the best effect.”

All the evidence shows that school meal programs and other social protection initiatives are one of the smartest long-term investments any government can make, the WFP stated in a February report.

“The return on investment can be as high as $9 for every $1 invested in implementing school feeding programs,” the report explained.

This article was originally published by Caixin Global. It has been republished here with permission.

(Header image: Students have free lunch at a primary school in Hefeng County, Hubei province, March 16, 2021. Yang Shunpi/People Visual)