Chinese Students in Limbo for Months Waiting for US Visas
If Wei Lan — a pseudonym — hadn’t returned to China in December for the winter holiday, today he would be sitting in a classroom at the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign, continuing his studies as a doctoral student. For the last three months, he has been anxiously awaiting the student visa that will allow him to return to his studies.
“Every day I feel more dead than alive. It’s so depressing,” Wei told Caixin.
The new semester began in January, and Wei has completed a year and a half of doctoral classes. If he gives up now, the last two years of hard work will be lost forever.
Though there are no official statistics, Wei’s case is not uncommon.
Since early March, many Chinese students who have not been able to return to the U.S. for the most recent semester have been organizing through a group on social media app WeChat in the hopes of raising awareness of their plight. Many came back to China at the end of 2018 for winter vacation — but have since suffered through a long and opaque administrative process.
Some of the groups quickly grew to have more than 100 members. Some students have already completed their undergraduate studies in China and have been working on masters or doctoral degrees in engineering or the sciences in the U.S. Others are studying in the fields of artificial intelligence, aviation, or the material sciences.
In May 2018, the Associated Press reported that the State Department was planning to shorten the validity length of student visas for Chinese students studying a master’s or doctorate in robotics, aviation, or high-end manufacturing.
These areas have been particularly sensitive in recent years. A policy notice issued in 2015 from China’s Cabinet, the State Council, outlines the “Made in China 2025” plan to upgrade China’s industrial sector, specifically aimed at improving machinery, aviation, and intelligent manufacturing, among others.
The shortened validity length meant that if students left the U.S. to return home or go to another country for any reason, they would have to apply for a new visa.
China’s Foreign Ministry slammed the move, with spokesperson Hua Chunying saying that China and the U.S. should facilitate “people-to-people exchanges” instead of “doing the opposite” at a regular press conference after the changes were announced.
Of course, students can also choose to stay in the U.S., because a foreigner’s legal residence period is determined by the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services. In short, a student visa is just a permit for entering and leaving the U.S.
“My major in the U.S. is computer science. It’s related to AI, but what I’m doing is for civil use; I don’t think it’s anything sensitive,” complained Wang Nan, the pseudonym of a doctoral student who has been waiting for his visa since December.
On March 7, branches of the Chinese Students and Scholars Association at the University of Illinois-Urbana Champaign; the University of California, Berkeley; and Cornell University published an open letter to gather support for a petition about the issue.
What the students don’t understand is why their visa applications, submitted at the end of last year, have been held up for so long.
According to the State Department website, visas have two statuses: approved or denied. However, the visa office can implement “administrative processing” for visa applicants who may be denied — a process with no time limit. With the tightening of student, work, and business visas, more applicants have required extra investigations, which have extended the normal administrative processing period.
“Before I came home, I had heard that U.S. visas were getting stricter, but I didn’t realize it would be this terrible,” Wei said. In the U.S., he was studying condensed matter physics in theoretical research — but such knowledge can also be applied to quantum computing. In 2017, his visa application underwent administrative processing, but it was approved in one month. It was valid for only one year.
But this time, with a tighter policy for U.S. visas, the review has disrupted Wei’s plans, and he seems to be caught in an international game of chess.
Targeted at Chinese students
In June 2018, at a congressional hearing on the Chinese student visa issue, Edward J. Ramotowski, deputy assistant secretary for visa services, confirmed that embassies and consulates had received special instructions to conduct additional investigations into Chinese students studying subjects in “sensitive areas.” He explained that the regulations were applicable to students studying for master’s, doctoral, and post-doctoral degrees. The “risk” for undergraduate students was not as high due to the more basic nature of their degrees.
Ramotowski said at the hearing that the new regulations were in accordance with President Trump’s National Security Strategy, announced in December 2017, and would prevent leaks of sensitive and patented technologies.
Ramotowski also acknowledged that excessive implementation could negatively impact America’s ability to attract talent and reduce the benefits contributed by foreign students. Bill Priestap, assistant director of the FBI’s Counterintelligence Division, revealed at the hearing that in 2017, international academics studying at U.S. colleges and universities contributed $36.9 billion to the U.S. economy and supported over 450,000 jobs. He added that three U.S. jobs were created for every seven academics enrolled.
According to statistics from the U.S. Department of Homeland Security, China is the largest source of international students to American universities: Of the 1.2 million foreign students in the U.S., 377,000 are from China.
But this has not stopped the U.S. from increasing the number of visas placed under “administrative processing.” Many Chinese students who have been investigated complained that America’s visa system is not transparent.
“We also don’t know what kind of things they’re investigating, we don’t know how the investigation is progressing, and we also don’t know if there’s even an investigation or if they’re just dragging it out,” a doctoral student who has been waiting for his visa since October told Caixin. “If there was a schedule, we could plan things, but no one can give us a timeline. We have no control.”
Most of the visa applicants interviewed by Caixin said that they had tried different channels to inquire about their visa application status, including sending endless emails to the American embassy and the State Department, and even calling U.S. congressional representatives, universities, or other organizations for help — all to no avail.
“The school can only let us extend our study period, but it can’t help us speak with the U.S. government. Through the whole process, there’s no one who can intervene,” Wang said.
In response to questions from Caixin, a spokesperson from the U.S. Embassy in Beijing said that visa applications are handled on a case-by-case basis, and it is up to the visa officer to determine whether a visa applicant’s situation meets the requirements laid out by U.S. law.
“We are always looking for mechanisms to improve our screening process. We hope to allow people to legally travel and immigrate to the United States while protecting U.S. citizens and national security,” the spokesperson said.
A lasting influence
Official statistics show that the U.S. is issuing fewer work visas than it once did. According to statistics from the U.S. Citizen and Immigration Services, in 2015, 96 percent of applications were approved. In 2018, this shrunk to 85 percent. During the approval process, the government has also required applicants to submit additional materials, thus lengthening the processing time.
Z. John Zhang, director of the Penn Wharton China Center, told Caixin that this could make it hard for foreign students to find work in the U.S. and reduce the motivation for foreign students to come to America for an MBA.
The new visa policies have also begun to affect regular academic exchanges. On March 7, Bao Yungang, director of the Chinese Academy of Sciences’ Research Center for Advanced Computer Systems, posted on WeChat that he and his colleague would miss a planning meeting for program chairs of the International Symposium on Computer Architecture — to be held in Arizona in June — because the U.S. government was still processing their visa applications.
Bao told Caixin that, especially for those in the fields of microchips and supercomputing, America’s visa policies have become increasingly strict. Since 2008, each of his visa applications has been subjected to administrative processing, and he has not been able to obtain a 10-year business visa.
Bao also felt that the processing time has gotten longer. Students from the Chinese Academy of Sciences who applied for U.S. visas were usually directly accepted, he said, but now they are often first put under administrative processing. He worries that this could impact academic exchanges between China and the U.S.
On the other hand, well-known foreign scholars are experiencing similar situations, showing that the visa restrictions are not limited to Chinese applicants. Adi Shamir, a world-renowned cryptographer and professor at the Weizmann Institute in Israel, recently had his visa application denied and was unable to attend a security conference in San Francisco in early March. His application had been placed under investigation over two months earlier.
For Chinese students who are still waiting for their visas, the potential cost of giving up their studies in America is too great. Many of them are still paying rent and have already paid tuition.
Some of the students in the WeChat group have received their visas, but many more are stuck waiting, without any idea of how long they will continue to do so or how they could speed up the process.
“If I don’t get my visa, I could consider transferring to a school in another country or ask my family members to help me find a job. I haven’t thought about it yet,” Wang said. But even after over 100 days of anxiety, his first choice is still to keep waiting.
This is an original article written by Zhang Erchi and Ren Qiuyu of Caixin Global and has been republished with permission. The article can be found on Caixin’s website here.
(Header image: People wait outside the U.S. Embassy in Beijing, Dec. 31, 2008. Stephen Shaver/VCG)